Journal of Ultrasound in Medicine, Vol 18, Issue 8 537-541, Copyright © 1999 by American Institute of Ultrasound in Medicine
Long-term prognosis of pregnancies complicated by slow embryonic heart rates in the early first trimester
P. M. Doubilet, C. B. Benson and J. S. Chow
Department of Radiology, Harvard Medical School and Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts 02115, USA.
Slow embryonic heart rates at gestational age 7 weeks or less are
associated with high risk of first trimester death. Our goal was to
determine the prognosis for those embryos with slow early heart rates who
survive the first trimester. We prospectively recorded embryonic heart
rates for all obstetrical sonograms obtained on singleton pregnancies at or
before 7.0 weeks' gestation since 1993. We collected information about
pregnancy outcome, including date of live birth or in utero death and
presence and nature of congenital anomalies. First trimester survival rate
was 61.6% among 531 embryos with slow early heart rates (< 100 bpm at
< or = 6.2 weeks, < 120 bpm at 6.3 to 7.0 weeks), lower than the
survival rate of 91.5% among 1501 embryos with normal heart rates (p <
10(-8), Fisher's exact test). Among 299 pregnancies in which the early
heart rate was slow and the fetus was still alive at the end of the first
trimester, 277 (92.6%) resulted in liveborn infants without congenital
anomalies, similar to the frequency of 95.1% in cases with normal early
heart rates (p > 0.10, Fisher's exact test). Structural and chromosomal
anomalies, however, occurred more than twice as frequently in cases with
slow early heart rates: 5.4% (16 of 299) of the first trimester survivors
with slow early heart rates proved to have anomalies, as compared to 2.4%
(31 of 1281) of cases with normal early heart rates (p < 0.05, Fisher's
exact test). In conclusion, a pregnancy in which the embryo has a slow
heart rate at or before 7.0 weeks' gestation and which continues beyond the
first trimester has a high likelihood (> 90%) of resulting in a liveborn
neonate without congenital anomalies. Embryos with slow early heart rates
do, however, have a greater risk of having anomalies than embryos with
normal early heart rates.