Journal of Ultrasound in Medicine, Vol 17, Issue 12 751-756, Copyright © 1998 by American Institute of Ultrasound in Medicine
Comparison of power Doppler and B-scan sonography for renal imaging using a sonographic contrast agent
C. M. Sehgal, P. H. Arger, C. R. Pugh, J. I. Kirchofer, E. Y. Kotlar and K. C. Bovee
Department of Radiology, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, USA.
The goal of this study was to evaluate the relative performance of power
Doppler and B-scan imaging modes in detecting vascular perfusion changes
resulting from injection of a contrast agent. To allow this comparison the
imaging plane and the contrast agent injection must be the same for both
modes. We achieved this by using a rigid transducer holder and
simultaneously recording power Doppler and B-scan images on separate
videotapes. The kidneys of five adult beagles were scanned to allow a
comparison of how power Doppler and B-scan imaging methods monitor changes
during the injection of 0.1 ml/kg of a contrast agent, EchoGen emulsion
(Sonus Pharmaceuticals, Bothell, WA). The changes in the images were
assessed qualitatively by three radiologists and quantitatively using a
custom-designed image analysis software. All of the radiologists agreed
that no visually detectable changes occurred in B-scan images but that
significant changes could be observed in power Doppler images. Image
analysis also indicated a difference between power Doppler and B-scan
images. The change in mean color level of power Doppler images could be
displayed as an indicator dilution curve with a peak enhancement of 46 +/-
16 above the preinjection value. The time at which mean color level peaked
was 18 +/- 13 s. The mean color level returned to half of the peak value by
69 +/- 42 s and returned to the preinjection baseline value by 148 +/- 73
s. Conversely, B-scan images showed statistically insignificant changes,
and time measurements could not be made. By all measures used to evaluate
images, power Doppler imaging had a greater sensitivity in detecting
changes resulting from contrast agent injection than B-scan imaging. This
finding indicates that power Doppler imaging of contrast agent injections
can be used to map regional differences in flow as well as quantitative
measurements of a contrast agent's transit time and has the potential to
assess kidney abnormalities associated with renal blood flow.